March 2020

Volume 37, Issue 1

Quantitative Bias Analysis of misclassification in casecontrol studies: an example with Human Papillomavirus and Oropharyngeal Cancer

Authors: Doris Durán Walid A. Al-Soneidar Sreenath A. Madathil Jay S. Kaufman Belinda Nicolau
doi: 10.1922/CDH_SpecialIssueNicolau06

Abstract

Objective: Laprise et al. (2019) observed a positive association between oral sex practices and oropharyngeal cancers (OPC) among HPVnegative individuals. Because oral HPV infections are likely to be transmitted through oral sex, these results are counterintuitive. We revisit Laprise et. al’s analysis with the objective of estimating the impact of misclassification of HPV infection on the association between oral sex practices and OPC. Methods: Data were drawn from the Head and Neck Cancer (HeNCe) Life study, a hospital-based case control study of head and neck cancer with frequency-matched controls by age and sex from 4 major referral hospitals in Montreal, Canada. We included only OPC cases (n = 188) and controls (n = 429) and used predictive value weighting, under differential and non-differential scenarios, to evaluate the misclassification. Subsequently, we used logistic regression and 95% confidence intervals to estimate the association between oral sex practice and OPC among HPV-negative individuals. Results: Our results showed that the previously reported association between oral sex practices and OPC among HPV-negative individuals was attenuated or nullified both under differential and non-differential scenarios. Conclusion: The association between oral sex practice and OPC could be explained by biases in the data (e.g., HPV mediator misclassification). Our results highlight the need for widespread adoption of Quantitative Bias Analysis in oral health research. Keywords: Head and neck cancer; HPV infection; Misclassification

Download

Other articles in this issue

Article Pages Access
Editorial: Brexit - Consequences for the UK’s Oral Health Workforce? 3-4 Download
The distribution of dentists in Australia Socio-economic profile as an indicator of access to services 5-11 Download
Alcohol consumption is associated with periodontitis. A systematic review and meta-analysis of observational studies 12-21 Download
Tobacco use and dental fear among 15-16 year-old adolescents in Finland 22-25 Download
Determinants of periodontitis among a rural Indian population: A case control study 26-31 Download
Effect of treating carious teeth on children’s and adolescents’ anthropometric outcomes: A systematic review of randomised controlled trials 32-38 Download
Perspectives of socially disadvantaged women on oral healthcare during pregnancy 39-44 Download
Assessing the conceptual model of the Oral Health Impact Profile-49 (OHIP-49): A path analysis 45-50 Download
Dentistry, e-health and digitalisation: A critical narrative review of the dental literature on digital technologies with insights from health and technology studies 51-58 Download
Retrospective analysis of the association between tooth loss and dementia: a population-based matched case control study 59-64 Download
Proceedings of EADPH Pre-Congress Workshop held on Wednesday, 11 September 2019 at Het Pand, University of Ghent, Belgium 65-82 Download
Random and Systematic Bias in Population Oral Health Research: an introduction 83-83 Download
Estimating Bias Due to Unmeasured Confounding in Oral Health Epidemiology [Special issue of Community Dental Health, to be disseminated at ‘Random and Systematic Bias in Population Oral Health Research’ IADR symposium, March 2020, Washington DC.] 84-89 Download
Bias in population oral health research: longitudinal studies [Special issue of Community Dental Health, to be disseminated at ‘Random and Systematic Bias in Population Oral Health Research’ IADR symposium, March 2020, Washington DC.] 90-95 Download
Quantitative Bias Analysis of misclassification in casecontrol studies: an example with Human Papillomavirus and Oropharyngeal Cancer 96-101 Download
Sources of bias in genomics research of oral and dental traits [Special issue of Community Dental Health, to be disseminated at ‘Random and Systematic Bias in Population Oral Health Research’ IADR symposium, March 2020, Washington DC.] 102-106 Download

Subscribe

Online (Single user only)
£150
Institution Online (IP address validation)
£250

Back issues may be obtained from the publisher

Consider recommending subscription to your institution's library

You can view Open Access papers without a subscription.