March 2014

Volume 31, Issue 1

Investigation of bias related to non-return of consent for a dental epidemiological survey of caries among five-year-olds

Authors: G.M. Davies M. Robinson J. Neville G. Burnside
doi: 10.1922/CDH_3306Davies06

Abstract

Estimates of caries levels derived from an epidemiological survey of five-year-olds in England were lower than expected. This survey used, for the first time, a consent method which involved parents providing positive, written consent for their child to be included in the survey. This contrasted to the previous method when negative consent was used. Aim: To interrogate the dataset to try and establish the reasons for the lower than expected estimates and explore the effect of non-return of parental consent, including the role of deprivation. Basic research design: Statistical analysis of an existing dataset and a sub-set of this dataset. Main outcome measures: Estimates of caries prevalence and severity in groups and sub-groups of a population-based, random sample of five-year-olds. Results: Hypotheses relating to possible changes in the process of data collection and analysis were rejected as reasons for the apparent reduction in disease estimates, as was the impact of oral and general health improvement programmes. Analysis of higher non-return levels on differences between past and current estimates and analysis of the associations between caries estimates, non-consent and summed deprivation measures based on home postcodes showed some relationships between these variables but could not identify a simple relationship. Conclusion: There is a more complex relationship between non-return of consent and disease levels than can be explained by deprivation alone. Key words: dental epidemiology, consent bias, socio-demographic indices

£10 single article

Other articles in this issue

Article Pages Access
Editorial - Reviews of the literature: Expected standards 2-3 £10 single article
Acknowledgement of Referees 4-4 £10 single article
Dental Public Health in Action - Developing and implementing a fluoride varnish programme for young children in Bradford, UK 5-8 £10 single article
The provision of dietary advice by dental practitioners: a review of the literature 9-14 £10 single article
Dentinal hypersensitivity: a narrative review 15-20 £10 single article
Investigation of bias related to non-return of consent for a dental epidemiological survey of caries among five-year-olds 21-26 £10 single article
Comparison of oral health among older people with and without dementia 27-31 £10 single article
Mothers’ sense of coherence and oral health related quality of life of preschool children in Udupi Taluk 32-36 £10 single article
Development and psychometric validation of a Health Literacy in Dentistry scale (HeLD) 37-43 £10 single article
Cross-cultural adaptation, validity and psychometric properties of the Spanish version of the dental satisfaction questionnaire 44-49 £10 single article
The incidence of cleft lip and palate in a Kurd population: a prospective study 50-52 £10 single article
The significance of motivation in periodontal treatment: Validity and reliability of the motivation assessment scale among patients undergoing periodontal treatment 53-56 £10 single article
Oral health behaviours and perceptions reported by Indigenous Australians living in Darwin, Northern Territory 57-61 £10 single article
Trends in the geographic distribution of dental clinics in Japan 62-64 £10 single article

Subscribe

Print
£130
Online (Single user only)
£130
Print & Online (Single user only)
£150
Institution Online (IP address validation)
£220

Back issues may be obtained from the publisher

Consider recommending subscription to your institution's library

You can view Open Access papers without a subscription.