June 2017

Volume 34, Issue 2

Productive efficiency and its determinants in the Community Dental Service in the north-west of England

Authors: Harry Hill Stephen Birch Martin Tickle Ruth McDonald Paul Brocklehurst
doi: 10.1922/CDH_4028Hill05


Objectives: To assess the efficiency of service provision in the Community Dental Services and its determinants in the North-West of England. Setting and sample: 40 Community Dental Services sites operating across the North-West of England. Basic Research Design: A data envelopment analysis was undertaken of inputs (number of surgeries, hours worked by dental officers, therapists, hygienists and others) and outputs (treatments delivered, number of courses of treatment and patients seen) of the Community Dental Services to produce relative efficiency ratings by health authority. These were further analyzed in order to identify which inputs (determined within the Community Dental Services) or external factors outside the control of the Community Dental Services are associated with efficiency. Main outcome measure: Relative efficiency rankings in Community Dental Services production of dental healthcare. Results: Using the quantity of treatments delivered as the measure of output, on average the Community Dental Services in England is operating at a relative efficiency of 85% (95% confidence interval 77%- 99%) compared to the best performing services. Average efficiency is lower when courses of treatment and unique patients seen are used as output measures, 82% and 68% respectively. Neither the input mix nor the patient case mix explained variations in the efficiency across Community Dental Services. Conclusions: Although large variations in performance exist across Community Dental Services, the data available was not able to explain these variations. A useful next step would be to undertake detailed case studies of several best and under-performing services to explore the factors that influence relative performance levels. Key words: Dental auxiliaries, Economics, Mid-level provider, Efficiency, Production


Other articles in this issue

Article Pages Access
Factors affecting dental fluorosis in low socioeconomic status children in Mexico 66-71 Download
Use of Jamaican Sign language in the provision of dental health care 72-76 Download
Communities in action: developing a dental ambassador training programme for adults with learning disability 77-79 Download
Improving Care for Bariatric Dental Patients in North Wales 80-83 Download
Public health intervention over four decades for the children in the Australian Capital Territory: Have we reached the point of diminishing returns? 84-87 Download
Relationship between mental health risk factors and oral symptoms in adolescents: Korea Youth Risk Behavior Webbased Survey, 2013 88-92 Download
What proportion of caries into dentine at age 5 is present at age 3? 93-96 Download
PeP-SCOT a health coaching intervention for people in prisons: the development of the intervention protocol 97-101 Download
Productive efficiency and its determinants in the Community Dental Service in the north-west of England 102-106 Download
Caries prevalence and treatment needs in young people in Portugal: the third national study 107-111 Download
Socio-demographic and area-related factors associated with the prevalence of caries among preschool children in Greece. 112-117 Download
Dental caries experience, rather than toothbrushing, influences the incidence of dental caries in young Japanese adults 118-121 Download
Ethnic Disparities in Oral Health Related Quality of Life among Adults in London, England 122-127 Download


Online (Single user only)
Institution Online (IP address validation)

Back issues may be obtained from the publisher

Consider recommending subscription to your institution's library

You can view Open Access papers without a subscription.